The Darwin-Hitler connection debunked

The anti-science creationists (and there really is no other kind) often try to discredit evolutionary theory by claiming that Nazi philosophy was inspired in part by Darwin’s writings. The ever-ignorant lizard bitch Cao has supplied an excellent example of this sort of fallacious thinking. Over at Pharyngula, PZ Myers highlights the work of a commenter at his site who puts this myth to bed permanently:

First of all, as has already been established courtesy of searching through Mein Kampf in detail, Hitler’s assorted eructations on nature reproduce well-known creationist canards, including the static species fallacy, and Hitler also asserted that fertile, viable hybrids were impossible…

Additionally, the Nazis placed textbooks on evolutionary biology on their list of seditious books to be burned, as illustrated nicely here, where we learn that in 1935, Nazi guidelines with respect to seditious books included:

6. Schriften weltanschaulichen und lebenskundlichen Charakters, deren Inhalt die falsche naturwissenschaftliche Aufklärung eines primitiven Darwinismus und Monismus ist (Häckel).

Translated into English, this reads:

Writings of a philosophical and social nature whose content deals with the false scientific enlightenment of primitive Darwinism and Monism (Häckel)

The evidence is therefore conclusive. Nazism was not inspired by evolution, and indeed, much of Hitler’s own writings are creationist in tone. The Nazis destroyed evolutionary textbooks as seditious (much as modern day creationists would love to)…

So much for that fantasy. I’m sure that the facts won’t deter Cao and others of its kind from continuing to make this ridiculous claim, of course.

  1. More interesting:
     
    I find it amusing that Cao spends so much time talking about evolution as a ‘racist’ idea, yet last time I checked her ilk makes it a point to hate everything that’s not white.  I mean yeah, they find excuses that they believe are reasonable but still…..
     
     
    just an observation….

  2. These guys are still lapping up Jonah Goldberg’s insane assertion that Nazis were really left wingers.  Anyone who can swallow that can swallow anything.
    Cao has repeatedly published the most ludicrous assertions about the Nazis- things that anyone who had ever read a book or two about them, or watched the Military channel, would immediately recognize as bald faced lies.  And just try to tell the truth in her comments section- an instant way to get banned, as I did for that “crime.”

  3. What does it even matter anyway?  It’s all just covered under Godwin’s law.
    Look, the left wing has nothing in common with the Nazi’s.  The right wing has nothing in common with the Nazi’s.  Maybe you’ll find a hair belief that is similar, but you’d probably find that same minuscule belief with any ideology.
     
     

  4. There’s also the fact that even had Hitler overtly and vehemently claimed that Darwinian theory was uniquely responsible for his views, this wouldn’t make Darwin either responsible or wrong. Maybe the existence of Mein Kampf implies that whoever invented the printing press was evil? Fucking idiots.